Dale, you can't blame Pinterest for the fact that it can be used by unscrupulous thieves. Pinterest tries to do the right thing by pinning a full link back to the original image. That was all I was saying about Pinterest.
As for right clicking, you can do that with any image, anywhere on the web, so long as it's displayed as a standalone image. I hope nobody thinks that disabling right-click protects their images for more than three seconds. That being how long it takes to disable JavaScript, which in turn enables right clicking.
As for the other person's assertions that stealing images for your own use is not copyright violation, you need to get your facts straight. I'm not an expert on all laws in all countries, but in my country you are highly unlikely to end up in court for keeping a copy for your personal scrapbook, so long as you never attempt to publish that scrapbook. However, if the author has accompanied his/her images with a copyright statement saying no image or part of any image may be used for any purposes whatsoever (that includes personal use by students for reference material) without the express permission of the author, then you had better hope you don't get caught.
If you steal someone's image, whether from a web page or a magazine page, then use it in your own publication, you are, in my country, in breach of copyright. If you go even further and try to claim that image as your own, you are in BIG trouble. That's not just copyright infringement, it's intellectual property theft. I appreciate some backward countries don't take any of that seriously, but my country does and I believe the US is much the same, except for their ludicrous requirement for creators to register everything they create on the national (NOT international) copyright database.
A.
--- In selling_stock_photography@yahoogroups.com, RK <rolf.krohna@...> wrote:
>
> Technology is changing, and that drives change in attitude. Nothing you
> can do about it but to follow it, and make use of it to your own advantage.
>
> If you cut out a picture from the magazine and glue it into your scrap
> book, it has never been considered a copyright violation. Saving a
> picture from your screen is just about the same thing, but
> electronically, and interpretation of copyright in most places see it
> just that way, with exceptions. Many also see it the same way if you use
> a copied picture on your personal web site, which is your electronic
> scrap book, which you show to friends.
>
> If you are smart, not all people are, you put your email address, name
> or logo on the picture itself, and for everyone who saves it to their
> electronic scrap book, you got a free of charge sales commercial for
> your work.
>
> It is interesting to watch the development in China, where I work. Going
> back a long time, copyright did not exist. Now, artists, singers,
> musicians, painters, sculptors, and photographers, fight to get their
> work displayed everywhere on the internet. The more "pirating" the more
> fame and the more people knowing them, and they can charge more for
> their "real work". That eliminate the middle men, as the media industry
> we have in the west, primarily USA. The vigorous campaigns against
> "piracy" by them has little to do with piracy at all, that is just the
> smoke screen, it has to do with maintaining hegemony, control, and
> dominance. We photographer has no changes on that. We would be better
> off without the dominant media industry.
>
> If you don't change with the times and the technology, you'll go the
> same way as the dinosaurs.
>
>
>
>
> On 14/08/2012 7:06 AM, Dale wrote:
> >
> > I'm relatively new to photography (30 years interrupted by about 15
> > years), but I've been in computers a long time. All you need to do to
> > steal an image from Pinterest is right click on the image and select
> > "Save Image As . . ." Most browsers have this capability and once
> > you've downloaded it, you can put it anywhere you like with no credit
> > to anyone you don't want to give credit to.
> >
> > You can even claim it as your own if you'd like.
> >
> > I have a Pinterest account and have validated that you CAN do what I
> > just described.
> >
> > I'm sure Pinterest doesn't encourage piracy, but it doesn't do much to
> > prevent it.
> >
> > Dale
> > // /
> > /"Good Enough" is the enemy of "Excellence"
> > However, "Overkill" is the enemy of "Productivity".
> >
> > ----------------------------------------------------------
> >
> > *From: *"Avril Jones" <aj@...>
> > *To: *"selling stock photography"
> > <selling_stock_photography@yahoogroups.com>
> > *Sent: *Monday, August 13, 2012 1:47:27 PM
> > *Subject: *Selling Stock Photography Re: Acclaim/Pinterest
> >
> > Angie, I totally understand your concerns about what happens to
> > your images. However, although I've seen many and varied
> > 'warnings' that Pinterest is a terrible site that encourages
> > copyright infringement etc, a good look at it suggests otherwise.
> >
> > If you have a Pinterest account and install the button on your
> > browser toolbar, whenever you see something you like on any site,
> > anywhere, you can click the button to 'Pin it' and choose the
> > element of the page that you want to feature. Pinterest then
> > posts it on your chosen subject board (you create your own
> > categories) as a link back to the original page. That way the
> > author of the image is effectively credited and more attention is
> > attracted to their work by Pinterest members pinning and sharing
> > it. Unless, of course, someone has already stolen your picture
> > the Pinterest member has found it posted where it shouldn't have
> > been. That would not be Pinterest's fault.
> >
> > I would suggest you go and have a browse for yourself and see what
> > I mean. You may still not wish to allow people to use that site
> > to praise and promote your work and, if that's the case, I think
> > there might be a tool you can use on your own website that lets
> > Pinterest know you don't want any of your content pinned. Not
> > absolutely sure about that last bit, but I've certainly clicked
> > the Pin It button to find that certain images/content on a site
> > cannot be pinned.
> >
> > I don't think I'd mind people pinning my work, unless they somehow
> > got access to a photo that wasn't meant to be publicly viewable.
> >
> > Hope that helps.
> >
> > Avril
> >
> >
> >
> >
>
